Telaah Komparasi Sunni-Sh?’ah atas Hadith Imamah dari Quraysh

Abstract

The Sunni-Sh?'ah tug-of-war seems to be never-ending, especially the the issue of the Imamate. The Sh?'ah have no qualms about claiming that as the the successor of the Prophets, the Imam must have the advantage of divinity such as prophethood which is directly chosen by God. The Sunnis, on the other hand, take a different view in principle. The difference between the two culminated when the Sh?'ah used the hadith in the authoritative hadith books belonging to the Sunnis, namely Sahih Bukhari and Muslim. It is clear from the research that there is no evidence to suggest that the hadith in Sahih Muslim It is clear from the research that there is no evidence to suggest that the Sahih Muslim contains any mention of the 12 Imams they believe in. The scholars seem inclined to judge that the state of the ummah would be unified in support their caliph, as if it were covered up in order to justify the Sh??? charge. justify the Sh?'ah isna 'ashariyah's indictment of their imams. imams. For, the state of the ummah in Sh?'ah history has not been found to be the people in Sh?'ah history were not found to be in one view; rather, they tended to be at odds with each other. with each other.